Digital Comics Inkwell

Digital Comic Fanboy Ramblings of a life long fan and sometime creator...

Search

The "Change" myth of writing

A recent blog post from a writer of comics and long form fiction included the following statement in a blog post about "GOOD STORY":

"A good story doesn't allow them to be the same person at the end they were at the beginning."

Writers/Authors/Creators who blog about their craft often site this as a given fact even though there are hundreds of examples that debunk it. 

Read any Robert B. Parker (or Crais or MacDonald or Stark or countless others) book and the characters in them are not changed in any way at the end of any one book.  They are not changed (with the exception of being updated over time - which is not what the above statement is about) over the course of a series.  They are not changed by a television series or movie made about them.

Books


Spenser (as well as Hawk, Elvis Cole, Joe Pike, Travis McGee and Parker) is the same man in every Robert B. Parker book.  Period.  In fact, the books are written from the stand point that Spenser is as good as he is BECAUSE he WON'T change.

In film James Bond is portrayed exactly the same way.  All of the peripheral characters: Moneypenny, Q, and M complain about how much he won't change movie after movie.

Bond

In comics Batman is the same way.  Alfred, Dick, Tim, and Barbara are always getting on him about taking a case to personally.  About not getting enough sleep.  About not going out in public as Bruce Wayne enough to keep up his cover identity.

Why do many Writers/Authors/Creators feel as if a GOOD story HAS to involve the primary character(s) changing?  Are Parker's books not good?  Are James Bond movies not good?  Are Batman comics not good?

Please feel free to weigh in here with comments....

2 comments
Jan 13, 2012
Danial said...
I've never even heard of this concept. The Bond and Batman examples completely debunk this theory. If it WERE true, neither would have endured as long as they have.
Jan 13, 2012
Caine Dorr said...
Exactly

Leave a comment...

Caine Dorr

Caine Dorr

Caine is the creator of the web fiction serial and podcast MASKED MARAUDER MATINEE as well as the free webcomic the PALADIN BRIGADE. He is a reporter of comic books, an illustrator, and writer of adventure fiction at his author site Caine Dorr
My Other Sites
TwitterFacebookmetaweblog
Subscriptions